活法 The Practice Shadow Notebook Ataraxia
Scrapbook spread — four kraft cards, charcoal ink, the concept of Ataraxia laid out like found objects
Ataraxia
ah-tah-rak-SEE-ah  ·  one philosophical concept
01
Choppy sea above a ruled waterline, flat below — The Practice, Ataraxia
02
Hand throwing a sponge at a half-finished horse painting — he had stopped trying
03
Walking figure, long shadow behind, one arrow reaching forward into nothing — it comes behind you or not at all
04
the arguing stopped
↑ to the head
this did not
↑ to the body
Notes
01 / What it says

What it says

The calm of having put the question down, not of having settled it.

心里那场争论停了,不是赢了。

02 / Where it comes from

Where it comes from

Pyrrho of Elis (c. 365–275 BC) wrote nothing down. Sextus Empiricus set it out around 200 AD, in Outlines of Pyrrhonism, Book I, chapter 12.

皮浪一个字没留。五百年后才有人替他写下来。

03 / How to try it today

How to try it today

One question you have been re-arguing for weeks: today, do not settle it. Say you don't know, and go and do the next thing.

有件事我翻来覆去想了很久,今天不定了。这话说着容易。

04 / Its honest limit

Its honest limit

By his own account it arrived by chance, once they had given up trying for it — Apelles only got the froth when he threw the sponge away — so it cannot be aimed at. And the promise was narrow: quiet in matters of opinion, moderate feeling in what cannot be avoided.

他自己说,是不求了以后才来的。求就求不到。它管的只是想法,冷还是冷。

a- + tarassein: not stirred up
Apelles threw the sponge
it followed, like a shadow
opinions only, never the cold